top of page
County Courthouse in Shelbyville, Illinois
Shelbyville Mutual Insurance Company Logo


 A home-town company with local staff, agents and adjusters from the community, partnering with Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company to provide Personal & Farm liability coverage for our package policies, we offer the stability and longevity you want in an insurance company.


Our products are geared toward providing you with the coverage you need for your farming operation, home and personal property, rentals, mobile homes and more. See each category of coverage products we offer and talk to one of our agents to answer any questions you may have.


Insurance can be complicated, so it is important to have a trusted partner who will assist you through the assessment, evaluation and coverage options to ensure your risk is covered. Contact one of our Shelbyville Mutual Agents to Join the Legacy today…and Trust In Tomorrow ®

Image by Michael Bourgault


Shelbyville Mutual Insurance Company was organized in 1889 as the Rose Township Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Company and operates pursuant to the Farm Mutual Act of 1986. Our office is located in Shelbyville, Shelby County, Illinois. With the purpose of safeguarding its members against loss or damage by any peril or perils resulting in physical loss or damage to property.




Thanks for submitting, we'll be in touch soon!

bottom of page